EU welfare reforms could encourage low earners not to work
13/11/2015
Government plans to stop EU migrants claiming in-work benefits would encourage some British workers to give up their job, according to some government officials.
The prime minister is making welfare reform within the EU a key demand ahead of the proposed in-out referendum.
However, the current demands to stop EU migrants from claiming in-work benefits will most likely have to be scrapped, as it is prohibited under EU law to impose “additional requirements on EU workers that do not apply to a member state's own workers.”
Therefore, it is widely accepted that in order to pass the reforms that David Cameron has demanded, an EU treaty change would be needed, which is something that EU leaders are insistent will not happen.
Alternative options
The current situation has meant that government ministers are looking at alternative options to curb in-work migrant benefits, many of which would mean that thousands of UK nationals would also become ineligible for these benefits.
One option that is being considered is to stop people claiming in-work benefits, unless they received unemployment benefits in the previous 12 months.
However, this has been heavily criticised, as it would mean that some people would benefit financially by temporarily giving up their job.
A second proposal that is being considered by Treasury officials is to introduce a four year residency period before becoming eligible for in-work benefits. However, some families would be thousands of pounds worse off if one family member found a job, further discouraging people from working.
Additionally, this plan has been criticised for discriminating against young adults, as an 18 year old would have to wait until they are 22 years old before becoming eligible for the benefits.
A third option would deny in-work benefits to people who have not paid a certain level of National Insurance contributions over a three year period. However, this would be difficult to implement as it would change the newly introduced Universal Credit system, and could make EU migrants eligible for out-of-work benefits too.
“Appalling”
The proposals have come under heavy criticism by government officials and politicians, as they could hit UK families and discourage people from working.
Nigel Farage, leader of UKIP, said that the prime minister was failing in his renegotiation of Britain’s EU membership. He said:
"Even the one area where he was going to go to the European Council and try to get a rule change, actually we've surrendered already by saying we will change the British social security system.
"So young couples in this country, aged 21, who work and have got children, will, if this goes ahead, be better off not working than being in work. I think it's appalling."
However, despite this criticism, it is believed that the prime minister remains confident that he can achieve welfare reform from his EU negotiations.
Need financial advice?
If you have any personal finance questions related to this news article, then please contact our financial advisers. You can get in touch by asking a question online, calling us on 0800 092 1245, or by arranging a visit.
Share this..
Related stories
Which way will the Irish economy move?
Yesterday's news that the 10 year yield on Irish government bonds has reached 6.78% saw a number of investors running for the hills amid concerns that the bailout of Anglo Irish bank could top the $35 billion forecast by credit rating agency S&P. This is a bitter blow for the Irish authorities who have battled all week to contain a situation which has the potential to run out of control fairly qui...
Read MoreTreasury remains upbeat despite GDP figures
The UK Treasury Department has remained fairly beat, citing expectations that the UK economy will rebound in the second half of 2009, despite greatly disappointing GDP figures this week. The fall of 0.8% in the economy in the second quarter of 2009 was significantly greater than the 0.3% forecast by many analysts although the Treasury had actually forecast a reduction of around 1%. Why this reduct...
Read MoreAdam Posen calls for new quantitative easing programme
Adam Posen, a member of the powerful MPC, has today come out with a keynote speech suggesting that the Bank of England needs to inject further capital into the UK economy sooner rather than later. He believes that now is the time to reintroduce the quantitative easing programme which has already swallowed up £200 billion although a statement on the additional investment potentially required has n...
Read MoreBank of England to gain new powers of secrecy
The UK government is looking to push through a number of changes to the financial industry one of which will allow the Bank of England to refrain from printing a weekly statement of accounts, and may allow them to hide a number of economic strategies. There are concerns that the move will see the UK government in conjunction with the Bank of England flood the UK market with newly printed money as...
Read MoreHSBC announce 500 job cuts
In a move which has been labelled disgraceful by the unions, it has been revealed that HSBC is to axe 500 employees in the run-up and Christmas. The move had been widely expected in financial circles but the timing of the announcement has attracted much criticism from a number of parties. The unions believe there is no business reason for the job cuts but HSBC has highlighted the fragile nature of...
Read More