Millions of private parking tickets could be ‘illegal’
20/02/2015
The RAC Foundation has argued that millions of parking tickets enforced on private land should be deemed illegal, meaning some drivers could be due refunds.
On behalf of the RAC Foundation, barrister John de Waal QC said that some penalties could be unenforceable in court, and therefore illegal.
His reasoning for deeming some parking tickets as illegal, is that the level of fine is often disproportionate to the loss that landowners have suffered as a result of somebody parking on their land.
The foundation has called for this argument to be tested in court, whilst they have also said that the government should look to ensure that any private parking fines should be “reasonable and enforceable”.
In 2012, the act of clamping, blocking-in, towing or immobilising a vehicle without permission from a lawful authority was made illegal. However, whilst this law has generally stopped rogue clamping firms abusing their powers, the RAC Foundation claimed that landowners are now using extortionate penalty charges as an alternative.
They said that some drivers have fined in excess of £100 for parking longer than the time they have paid for, and in once case, a woman was charged £100 for overstaying in a car park that charged just 20p per hour.
Establish a precedent in law
Speaking about this legal argument, Professor Stephen Glaister, the director of the foundation said that he wants their argument tested in a higher court of law, so that a legal precedent is set.
He also referenced a case that will be taken to the court of appeal next week, which involves a motorist who was given an £85 parking fine.
Mr Glaister said that if the motorist was to win the case, then a precedent in the law could be established, and those who have been overcharged in the past “will find that that charge is unenforceable in the courts” and that they “will have a case to get that money repaid."
Patrick Troy, who works for the British Parking Association added: "The genuine pre-estimate of loss argument has been a bone of contention for many years and so we look forward to the Court of Appeal reaching a decision."
Need financial advice?
If you have any personal finance questions related to this news article, then please contact our financial advisers. You can get in touch by asking a question online, calling us on 0800 092 1245, or by arranging a visit.
Share this..
Related stories
Are the Boxing Day sales enough to kick start the UK economy?
Retailers around the UK have been reporting massive sales today with shoppers out in force to grab the best of the bargains after Christmas. Many have been surprised by the substantial amount of money seemingly available to the UK consumer after months of concern about where the sales were going to come from. So have we reached the bottom of the retail market?
While there is no doub...
Will alternative energy sources really dominate the UK in the future?
Over the last few days we have seen the UK government highlighting the potential benefits of wind power with over 6,000 new wind turbines expected to be introduced to the shores of the UK over the next 10 years. The government believes that upwards of 50% of UK homes could receive their power from alternative energy sources in the future but there is some confusion and disbelief regarding the figu...
Read MoreIs Tiscali doomed to failure?
Broadband giant Tiscali is said to be on the verge of collapse this evening with auditors Ernst & Young unwilling to sign off the 2008 accounts. Shares in the company were suspended some time ago as talks regarding the sale of the UK broadband arm collapsed and the group was faced with a debt mountain of over £450 million. Unable to keep up repayments the company agreed to a suspension of the sha...
Read MoreSatellite TV company Setanta on verge
Irish satellite TV company Setanta is this evening on the verge of a remarkable recovery with news that a US billionaire has offered a £20 million lifeline in exchange for a majority stake in the business. Leonard Blavatnik has put forward a plan for the business which would see his company invest £20 million for a 51% stake in the operation. This comes after a very difficult period for the Iris...
Read MoreIs the price of UK gas set to spiral higher?
The revelation by the National Grid that 50% of UK gas supplies will be imported over the next 12 months has dealt a significant blow to UK consumers. Despite the fact that the UK was actually a net exporter of gas back in 2003, due in the main to the North Sea oilfields, it would appear that the situation has deteriorated alarmingly over the last six years and the UK energy industry is now at the...
Read More