UK taxpayers lost £1bn on Royal Mail sale
14/07/2014
The privatisation of the Royal Mail could have lost UK taxpayers around £1bn, according to a select committee of MPs.
Royal Mail shares were priced at 330p when 60% of the company was floated on the stock market; however these have since peaked at 663p per share, and they now stand at around 473p per share.
The report was conducted by the Business, Innovation and Skills select committee, who claimed that the government received poor financial advice and set the price of the shares too low because of a fear of failure.
Adrian Bailey, a Labour MP and chair of the committee said: “We believe that fear of failure and poor quality advice led to a significant underestimate of the demand for Royal Mail shares”.
He then went on to state that “if any minister loses that sum of money to the public purse then they really should reconsider their position”.
However, business secretary, Vince Cable criticised the report, claiming that it contains “factual errors and misunderstandings”.
He said the committee who published the report “have the benefit of hindsight, which we didn’t have at the time”.
Cable then added: “The price of shares is very, very volatile – these things go up and down and we’ve seen in the last few weeks the price of Royal Mail shares actually falling like a stone”.
“Disturbed”
The report highlighted further concerns about the sale of the company, stating that the committee was “disturbed” the taxpayer may not have benefited from the sale of ‘surplus’ Royal Mail assets.
These assets included three sites in London, which had a ‘hidden value’ of up to £830m, according to the National Audit Office (NAO).
The NAO recommended that these assets should not have been included in the sale of the company, or an arrangement should have been made where they could claw back the proceeds of any future sales of those assets.
There was also concern that the correct measures to ensure those who advised the sale did not have a conflict of interest.
Lazard, UBS and Goldman Sachs were advisers to the sale, and they were all included as ‘preferred investors’, meaning they all had shares allocated to separate parts of their business.
Lazard and the banks are believed to have made millions of pounds on behalf of their clients by purchasing the shares before selling them on for a profit, shortly after the company was floated on the stock market.
Mr Bailey said: "It's very important that when the government does sell off a government asset, it does so through a process that quite clearly demonstrates that nobody selling it, nobody advising it, has a conflict of interest".
Need financial advice?
If you need to ask a financial question then please contact our financial advisers online or over the phone to get help with your query.
Share this..
Related stories
UK tax authorities confirm 27 MPs under investigation
The UK tax authorities have today confirmed that 27 members of Parliament are currently under investigation regarding their expenses. Not only are MPs under pressure from an internal parliamentary investigation into expenses, but the tax authorities are also investigating whether any tax laws have been broken by the 27 MPs in question.
In a rather interesting development, the tax au...
Two British local authorities set to sue Royal Bank of Scotland
We are moving headlong towards one of the most bizarre situations seen in legal history with two local authority pension schemes set to sue the Royal Bank of Scotland for "withholding information about the state of the company". As we have covered on a number of occasions in the past, there have been murmurings from shareholders regarding the massive rights issue last year with allegations that th...
Read MoreWas the Robin Hood tax vote rigged?
Earlier this week we saw a number of prominent politicians and showbiz celebrities step forward in support of a so called "Robin Hood tax" which would see a levy introduced on every financial transaction in the world to create a fund of around £250 billion a year. Richard Curtis, perhaps best known as the creator of the movie Love Actually, launched an online campaign to see what the public thoug...
Read MoreUK government issue £6 million grant to Vestas
As we covered just a few days ago, while the UK government was announcing plans to spend hundreds of millions of pounds on eco-friendly projects throughout the UK, the Danish owned turbine manufacturer Vestas announced plans to close its factory on the Isle of Wight. The timing of the announcements could not have been worse for the UK government with the Danish company citing the fact that wind tu...
Read MoreNorthern Rock could take a decade to pay back taxpayer loan
It has been revealed that the Northern Rock could take more than a decade to pay back the billions of pounds owed to the UK government which came to the rescue of the banking operation when it was on the verge of collapse. This comes after news that the European Commission has approved plans for the UK government to split the bank into two separate operations, with the likelihood that the "good ba...
Read More