UK and Scottish governments clash on pensions analysis
24/04/2014
The UK government has claimed that for an independent Scottish government to meet the cost of pensions, they would have to fund an extra £450 per working age adult every year.
The analysis by the Department of Work and Pensions suggested that these increased costs could arise as soon as the early 2030s.
However, these claims have been refuted by key figures in Scottish government, as the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon said welfare and pension spending would be “more affordable” in an independent Scotland. She also criticised the UK government, claiming that they have started to “dismantle the welfare state”.
A resilient and unified system
Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith claimed that the UK can be “proud” of its “long history of a strong welfare state”.
He also said that: "As part of the UK, Scottish people benefit from this resilient and unified system, which delivers the same support everywhere irrespective of peaks and troughs in economies of the nations or demographic differences.”
He continued to say: "Proposals by the Scottish government would risk the well-being of vulnerable people who are currently supported by this system.
Additionally, Mr Duncan Smith criticised the Scottish government for committing to spending more money on welfare without sharing any plans of how they will pay for it. He further claimed this is especially concerning as the Scottish population is ageing faster than anywhere else in the UK.
‘Plucking figures out of thin air’
Ms Sturgeon dismissed the analysis from the UK government by claiming that “This is just another example of a UK government that is scaremongering and is plucking figures out of thin air to try and tell people in Scotland you can't do it - the message from this government and the Yes campaign is we can do it."
These comments came despite the Scottish Secretary in the UK government saying the current system was “fantastic” and that it “worked very well”.
Need advice?
If you need to ask a financial question then please contact our financial advisers online or over the phone to get help with your query.
Share this..
Related stories
Pension loophole could cost the Treasury millions
As the furore regarding the introduction of the 50% tax rate in the UK starts to calm down it has been revealed that a loophole in the regulations will allow those pulled into the 50% tax band to claim back 50p out of every pound they contribute to their pension schemes. In a move which undermines Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown's attempt to tax the rich and help low-income families this will co...
Read MoreScottish Widows to be named in £1bn pension advice case
Insurance giant Scottish Widows could be facing legal action over claims it misadvised pension schemes. In a dossier compiled by the Actuarial Review Company (Arc), which has been sent to the Financial Services Authority, it is alleged that as a result of the company's advice 100 pension schemes lost £300 million. The advice alleged to have been given by the insurer was to switch from guaranteed...
Read MoreWill your pension be hit by the BP collapse?
As problems at BP continue to grow there are fears that many people in the UK could be hit by the collapse in share price. This is a company which has for some time been one of the largest components of the FTSE 100 and therefore a main component of many tracker funds and pension arrangements. As a consequence, it is highly likely that any stock market-based pension arrangement will have some expo...
Read MoreExpat pensioners lose court battle
The UK government is this evening breathing a sigh of relief after winning a European Court of Human Rights battle which could have resulted in a £500 million a year additional bill for the UK state pension. The case revolves around a number of expats who have moved overseas to places such as Australia and Canada and are currently only receiving the pension payable upon their retirement in the UK...
Read MoreBrits are ignoring pensions
Millions of Britons are throwing caution to the wind in failing to prepare for their retirement, a pensions expert has warned. According to Mark Brooks, spokesman for the National Association of Pension Funds, as many as seven million people are not saving "enough, if anything, for their retirement". However, in so doing, they are risking having to endure a disappointing and difficult retirement,...
Read More